Analysis of ethical case scenario Ethical Dilemmas:
What are ethical considerations? Ethics searches for reasons for acting or refraining from acting; for approving or not approving conduct; for believing or denying something about virtuous or vicious conduct or good or evil rules.
The way that individuals are affected by the conduct of others merits ethical consideration. The effects on a person of being informed that his father died of Huntington's disease and that, therefore, there is a fifty percent chance that he has inherited the genetic mutation can be personally and profoundly harmful.
The risk of harm to that person becomes an essential ethical consideration in deciding what information to disclose and how to disclose it.
That risk will need to be balanced against the ethical interests in respecting the autonomy of the person affected, and their choice about whether to know or not.
They are vulnerable to the effects of the information on their self-perception and disclosure of information on familial relationships and sense of privacy. He may also be concerned about how the privacy of this information will be protected and that the information not lead to differential treatment of himself or his descendants.
In these ways, individual interests are related to family and societal interests. To prohibit disclosure of genetic information, in order to prevent the kind of harm that a person at risk of Huntington's disease might suffer, may not adequately reflect the needs of others.
From balancing ethical considerations, flexible solutions may be derived that accommodate the interests of individuals and the needs of families and society. As DP 66 explained: Indeed, the answers to some of the questions posed in this Inquiry are already provided by existing laws.
For example, privacy laws prohibit the collection, use or disclosure of genetic information without consent, except in limited circumstances. Similarly, anti-discrimination laws prohibit the reliance on genetic information in ways that are unfair.
Ethics brings together and integrates relevant interests, individual, familial, community and societal. Ethics can have an integrative function in the context of biotechnology: The Canadian moral theorist Thomas Hurka put this point well in a book on the ethics of global warming: An ethical judgement about climate policy is not just one judgement among many, to be weighed against economic, political, and other judgements in deciding how, all things considered, to act.
It is itself an all-things-considered judgement, which takes account of economic and other factors. If a climate policy is right, it is simply right; if it is ethically wrong, it is wrong, period. Rather a sound ethical judgement involves an integration of all the relevant factors.
|What are ethical considerations?||People who work with young children, or in child protective services Lawyers and paralegals Administrators of all types of community programs or their sponsoring organizations Non-professional line staff home health aides, overnight staff at residential facilities and shelters In some states, many of these people -- medical personnel, mental health workers, social workers, educators and others who work with children and youth -- are legally considered mandated reporters. A mandated reporter is required by law to report any suspected instance of child physical or sexual abuse or child neglect.|
|Resources In This Article||Medical Malpractice The law has a lot to say about personal decision-making.|
|You are here||How to Write a Summary of an Article?|
Since expert judgement is relevant in the recognition and understanding of relevant factors and their interplay, combined expertise is essential. In this joint endeavour, what ethicists can contribute on the basis of the ethical theory and work in applied ethics is help in understanding the complex ways in which integrative judgements can be made, criticised and justified.
Ethics contains statement about what is good or bad, what ought or ought not be done and the grounds for those assertions.
For instance, researchers ought, ethically, to seek consent from people to use their genetic information in research because doing so respects their autonomy and freedom to choose. Or, on the other hand, researchers should be free to use coded genetic information in research without consent because that will enable more information to be used and better research to be conducted.
As a result, all members of society, including those whose information is used, will benefit. These statements are often called normative statements—they are statements about how, and why, people should behave. Acting to achieve the best outcome is, on the other hand, a justification based on consequences and not on principles.
Much of the content of this chapter uses normative statements. The chapter describes the range of ethical considerations that are likely to be drawn on in making and justifying decisions about genetic information.
The regulatory responses recommended in this Report to protect genetic information reflect a balance among these considerations.Legal Issues The legal implications of nursing practice are tied to licensure, state and federal laws, scope of practice and a public expectation that nurses practice at a high professional standard.
The nurse’s education, license and nursing standard provide the framework by which nurses are expected to practice. analyse the legal, ethical and operational issues in relation to the use of business information, using appropriate examples.
In this assignment I will be analysing the legal, ethical and operational issues in relation to the use of business information and relate it to . Business Communications Merit 2 I will analyse the legal, ethical and operation issues in relation to the use of business information, and by including appropriate examples.
Explaining legal and ethical tensions between maintaining confidentiality and sharing information Explain how to support effective communication within your own job role. Communication is constantly happening within the day care center and in my job role I have a responsibility to communicate with staff, service users and other professionals.
These ethical and legal responsibilities are largely concerned with matters of duty of care towards patients and the public, negligence in treatment and practice, a patient’s consent to treatment and procedures, and confidentiality of a patient’s personal and medical information.
Jul 01, · Ethical and legal dilemmas arise when the health care provider and the patient, or the patient’s family, have differing opinions on appropriate care. A health care professional may be torn between the ethics of beneficence (doing good) and autonomy (respecting patient’s wishes).